0800 002 5819 claims@claimrite.co.uk

What is Betterment in Insurance Claims Terms?

The betterment clause in UK home insurance policies pertains to situations where an insured property is enhanced beyond its pre-loss condition due to repairs or replacements funded by the insurance claim settlement. This enhancement, often referred to as betterment, occurs when the insured property ends up in a better state or condition than before the property damage that necessitated the claim. This improvement is often attributable to the installation of newer or upgraded materials, components, or fixtures, which inadvertently increase the property’s value, instead of restoring it to its same value before the loss.

Here are examples of when betterment may occur:

Upgrade to Building Materials

In the event of structural damage to a property, such as roof damage caused by severe weather, the insurance claim may cover the cost of repairs using more durable or higher-quality building materials than those originally used, maybe to comply with current building regulations. This is a form of betterment that commonly occurs and is accepted because the repairs will not be able to take place without the betterment occurring.

Modernisation of Electrical or Plumbing Systems

Following damage to electrical wiring or plumbing systems, the insured may choose to upgrade these systems to meet current safety standards or to improve efficiency, which could result in betterment. However, if the repair requires a brand new whole system to be installed, this is again a form of betterment that commonly occurs and is accepted, because the repairs will not be able to take place without the betterment occurring.

Remodelling or Renovation Opportunities

Damage to certain parts of the property, such as kitchens or bathrooms, may present an opportunity for the insured to undertake remodelling or renovation projects to replace them using insurance claim funds, leading to betterment. The insurer will need to pay up to the costs of a like-for-like replacement item, and the policyholder will be required to cover the additional costs.

Repair of Wear and Tear

In some cases, a property may have pre-existing wear and tear or deterioration that is unrelated to the covered loss. If repairs or replacements are made as part of the insurance claim settlement, the insured property may experience betterment by addressing these pre-existing issues. However, if the claim-related repairs are unable to take place without also repairing the worn and affected areas, then this is usually a form of betterment which is accepted.

Understanding Betterment in Insurance Cover

Betterment may seem advantageous to the insured, but it can also have significant implications on the insurance claim settlement process. An insurance policy may typically include provisions designed to prevent the insured from profiting from a covered loss. This often means that the insurance provider applies principles of indemnity to limit betterment.

Implications of Betterment in the Insurance Settlement Process

Indemnity refers to the principle that a policyholder should be restored to the same financial position they were in before the loss occurred, without gaining any advantage. Therefore, if betterment occurs, the insured may be responsible for covering the portion of the improvement costs that exceed the value of the property’s pre-loss condition.

In the following examples, we will see how these principles apply:

Examples of Betterment in Insurance

Appliance Replacement: If the insured chooses a newer, more expensive appliance, they may be responsible for covering the cost difference between the old and new appliances.

Upgrade to Building Materials: The insured might need to contribute to the cost difference between the standard and upgraded materials.

Cost Implications for Insured Individuals in Cases of Betterment

Modernisation of Systems: The insured may be required to pay the extra cost associated with upgrading the electrical or plumbing systems beyond their original condition.

Remodelling Opportunities: Any expenses related to aesthetic improvements or enhancements beyond the scope of necessary repairs may be the responsibility of the insured.

Addressing Wear and Tear: The Fine Line Between Restoration and Betterment

Addressing Wear and Tear: The insured may need to cover the portion of repair costs attributable to pre-existing wear and tear or deterioration, rather than damage caused by the covered loss. This is usually only applied in extreme cases.

The Balance between Insurance Settlement and Betterment

In essence, while betterment can lead to improvements in the insured property, it’s essential to understand that insurance settlements aim to restore the property to its pre-loss condition without providing a windfall to the insured. Therefore, any enhancements or upgrades resulting from the claim settlement may require the insured to contribute financially to offset the betterment.

How Betterment Affects Your Financial Contribution in Insurance Claims

It’s common sense that replacing a new item, such as a fitted kitchen, with an older item, is always a form of betterment. Therefore, most claim-related repairs could be interpreted as a form of betterment, which will affect the financial contribution required from the insured.

Can You Avoid Betterment in Home Insurance Claims?

While avoiding betterment in home insurance claims can be challenging, there are a few strategies that may help:

  • Understanding Your Policy: Thoroughly understand your insurance policy, including the fine print. Know what is covered and what isn’t. This can help you negotiate effectively during the claim settlement process.
  • Detailed Records: Keep detailed records of the condition and value of your property before any damage occurs. This can provide evidence of the pre-loss condition of your property.
  • Professional Assistance: Consider hiring a professional loss assessor to assist with your claim. They have expertise in dealing with insurance companies and can help ensure that you receive a fair settlement. Call 0800 002 5819 to discuss your situation.
  • Routine Maintenance: Regular maintenance can help prevent the argument that the property was in a deteriorated condition before the loss, which could lead to a betterment being applied.
  • Negotiation: If betterment is applied to your claim, don’t accept it without question. You can negotiate with the insurance company or seek advice from a loss assessor.

It’s important to remember the purpose of a contents insurance claim is to restore your personal belongings to their pre-loss condition, not to result in a financial gain for you as the policyholder. So, while you might not be able to entirely avoid betterment, these strategies can help you navigate the process more effectively.

Is It Worth Fighting Betterment?

 Yes, it can be worth fighting betterment in insurance claims. While the process can be challenging, several strategies can make your case stronger:

  • Negotiating with the Insurance Company: Negotiation is a key strategy in fighting betterment being applied. You can dispute the betterment by providing evidence of your property’s pre-loss condition or showing that the improvements were necessary to facilitate the required repairs.
  • Enlisting Professional Help: Some independent assessors like Claimrite have experience dealing with insurance companies and can help fight for you.
  • Understanding Your Policy: Knowledge of your insurance policy can also be beneficial. Knowing what’s covered and what isn’t can help you argue against unjust betterment being applied.
  • Disputing the Betterment: If you’re being directed towards the application of betterment in your claim, contact your insurer as soon as possible to begin the dispute process. Be sure to back up your claim with substantial evidence.

Contents & New-For-Old Insurance Cover

What is New For Old Insurance Cover?

Historically, insurance policies often offered “indemnity” cover for contents insurance only, which meant that in the event of a covered claim, the insurance provider would only pay out the current value of the damaged or lost items, taking into account depreciation due to age, wear and tear, or obsolescence. However, the introduction of “new for old” insurance cover represents a significant advancement in insurance protection, offering policyholders the opportunity to replace damaged or lost items with new equivalents, regardless of their age or condition at the time of the loss.

The concept of “new for old” cover emerged as insurers recognised the limitations of indemnity-based policies, which often left policyholders financially disadvantaged by receiving only partial compensation for their losses. With the rising costs of goods and changing consumer expectations, there was a growing demand for insurance coverage that provided more comprehensive protection for personal belongings.

The transition to “new for old” cover can be attributed to several factors and milestones in the history of insurance:

Consumer Expectations: As consumerism grew in the post-war era, individuals became accustomed to the idea of continuously upgrading and replacing their possessions with newer, better-quality items. This cultural shift influenced expectations regarding insurance coverage, with policyholders seeking greater assurance in insurance terms that they would be adequately compensated for their losses.

Advancements in Risk Assessment and Underwriting: With advancements in data analytics and risk assessment techniques, insurers became better equipped to accurately price and underwrite policies offering “new for old” cover. This enabled insurers to manage the increased risk associated with providing more generous cover while maintaining profitability.

Legislative and Regulatory Changes: Regulatory developments, such as the introduction of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 in the UK, which strengthened consumer protections and rights in relation to insurance contracts, may have influenced insurers to enhance their policy offerings, including provisions for “new for old” cover.

While “new for old” cover represents a significant improvement in the level of protection offered to policyholders, it’s essential to recognise that all such settlements involve an element of betterment. This is accepted because it is what your policy covers you for.

For example, if a policyholder’s five-year-old television is damaged in a covered loss and the insurer replaces it with a brand-new model of equivalent specification, the policyholder benefits from receiving a newer and potentially more advanced item than the one they lost. While this enhances the policyholder’s position compared to their pre-loss condition, it also represents a form of betterment. Again, this is what your policy covers you for, if you have ‘new-for-old’ cover.

If you do have ‘new-for-old’ cover, and your insurer tries to reduce your contents settlement by sighting wear and tear, or the general age of the items, do not accept it.

In summary, the introduction of “new for old” cover in UK insurance policies reflects a response to changing consumer expectations, competitive pressures, and advancements in risk assessment and regulation. While offering enhanced protection for policyholders, such settlements inherently involve a degree of betterment, where the insured may receive benefits beyond restoring them to their pre-loss condition.

What is important to remember is that if your insurance company tries to reduce your settlement based on a claim of potential betterment, you should always consider whether it falls into the normal course of claims handling. If it does, then don’t accept the reduction.

If you would like to speak to an expert about this or any other aspect of your claim, call our free Property Claim Helpline on 0800 002 5819, for a no-obligation consultation.


All content within this or any column, or via the free helpline, is provided for general information only, and should not be treated as a substitute for the Insurance advice of your own broker or any other insurance professional. Claimrite is not responsible or liable for any decisions made by a user based on the content of this site or the free helpline.

Claimrite is not liable for the contents of any external internet sites listed, nor does it endorse any commercial product or service mentioned or advised on any of the sites. Always consult your own Insurance broker if you’re in any way concerned about your insurance cover.